Pdf multiverse, mtheory, and god the creator wojciech. Parallel universes and god is there a contradiction. Some hours later, holmes awoke and nudged his faithful friend. What hawking said and why it matters by david hutchings. Does this mean that string theory predicts a multiverse. Sep 27, 2012 below is the table of contents for god vs the multiverse. Bayes, god, and the multiverse 3 detectives, shows that we understand a hypothesis as simple to the extent to which it postulates few substances entities, few kinds of substances, few properties, few kinds of properties, more readily observable properties, few relations between properties e. An astonishingly good read, gripping and thoughtprovoking william lane craig if you wanted to understand stephen hawking but couldnt face the maths, this is the book for you. The main problem with the multiverse proposal is that only one universe is to be observed, and that we effectively can only observe it from one spacetime point, says ellis. Mocombes structurationist theory of phenomenological. A response to stephen hawking revd dr rodney holder the faraday institute for science and religion, st edmund. Jan 01, 2014 having read at least a dozen books on cosmology over the last 8 years or so, i believe victor stengers book, god and the multiverse, is the best because he does such an excellent job of explaining difficult scientific concepts in ways that are understandable as he traces the historical development of cosmology from ancient times until the present. This multiple universe area has been postulated to contain not just alternate timelines of our existing universe. It could be that god is behind everything and we as physicists are just revealing god s handiwork, greene said.
When gods walk the world, clerics channel divine power, evil cults perform dark sacrifices in subterranean lairs, and shining paladins stand like beacons against the darkness, its hard to be ambivalent about the deities and deny their existence. After a good meal and a bottle of wine they lay down for the night and went to sleep. If you dont want god, you better have a multiverse. According to brian greene, professor of physics and mathematics at columbia university the two options, multiverse or god do not necessarily have to stand as rivals. This multiverse usually comes as a response to the design argument and in fact, even atheist icons, such as richard dawkins, are attaching themselves to this theory, and of course therefore popularizing it. All the galaxies we have just been talking about obey the same physics. Revd dr rodney holder the faraday institute for science and religion, st edmund. I discuss how multiverse models can be falsi ed and argue that there is a severe \measure problem that must be solved to make testable predictions at levels iiiv. Jan 02, 2020 the multiverse theory is based on the supposition that what we have to this point considered to be the universe is but a small component of a vast, possibly infinite, assemblage of universes. God does not survey all possible worlds and necessarily actualize those universes in the on balance good worlds or the worthy worlds. Augustine collective string theory, the multiverse, and god. God, the multiverse, and everything christians in science.
If one believes in god, or wonders whether to believe in god, this issue cries out to be addressed. The multiverse is not a monolithic concept and we will refer to. Monotheism the following video is the first part of a discussion between two of the most prominent atheistic scientists, richard dawkins and steven weinberg. Every universe is covered by seven layers earth, water, fire, air, sky, the total energy and false ego each ten times greater than the previous one. God, the multiverse, and everything rodney holder cis durham, 19. For some thinkers, these finetunings are evidence of the existence of god. Did the dying stephen hawking really mean to strengthen the case for god. A multiverse is vast infinity of existent universes, embracing the whole range of values of the constants and initial conditions. Page institute for theoretical physics department of physics, university of alberta room 238 ceb, 122 89 avenue edmonton, alberta, canada t6g 2g7 2008 january 17 abstract monotheistic religions such as judaism and christianity a. Insofar as the theory of such a multiverse is simpler than that of a single universe, and that theory makes good predictions, it. According to the multiverse hypothesis, the universe we live in is just one of an enormous, perhaps infinite, number. He has written several scientific papers on the multiverse measure problem and on the topic of god and the multiverse. All is created by god, and god creates by thinking, so its all divine ideas.
Dark matter by blake crouch, a thousand pieces of you by claudia gray, the long earth by terry pratchett, a darker shade of. That failure, then, will likely cast doubt on all multiverse theories, weakening the challenge to the conventional view of god. Newton fol lowed with his laws of motion and gravitational attraction. The idea is that if a multiverse exists you can then say. Some theist idealistsscotus erigena is an examplehold that there is no absolute distinction between the physical and the nonphysical. And so, assuming that string theory is true, it appears that there are at least 10500 possible universes like ours, with slightly different physics in each one. Carr views the only viable options as being either god or a multiverse the theory that there are a vast number of other universes. Pdf it has always started from the premise that the pattern of scientific knowledge is incompatible with the religious one. So he specifically develops and proposes the most elegant multiverse model so far but which makes specific predictions that he expects will be falsified. When gods walk the world, clerics channel divine power, evil cults perform dark sacrifices in subterranean lairs, and shining paladins stand like beacons against the darkness, its hard to be ambivalent about the deities and deny. The multiverse, also known as a maniverse, megaverse, metaverse, omniverse, or metauniverse, is a hypothetical group of multiple universes.
God and the multiverse1 abstract recent developments in quantum physics postulate the existence of some form of multiverse. Is it the case that the apparent finetuning of constants and forces to make the universe just right for life means there. Because mormonism teaches that jesus created the universe, yet his father, god the father, once dwelt upon an earth as a mortal, it may be interpreted that mormonism teaches the existence of a multiverse, and it is not clear if the other inhabited worlds mentioned in lds scripture and teachings refers to planets within this universe or not. Together, these universes comprise everything that exists. By background evidence i mean evidence about how things behave in areas outside the range that h purports to explain. Nowhere does the bible say that god has created only one universe. May 07, 2018 did the dying stephen hawking really mean to strengthen the case for god. Did the dying stephen hawking really mean to strengthen the.
We argue that a cosmology of many worlds is not novel either to philosophy or to theism. Pdf god and the multiverse max andrews and david beck. Below is the table of contents for god vs the multiverse. But now physicists are telling us, or at least asking us to consider, that we live in a multiverse of a much different sort. If god necessarily actualizes the multiverse, we have no idea which universes are parts of that multiverse. We will argue that a cosmology of many worlds is not novel either to philosophy or to theism. If there are multiple universes, did god create each of them.
Everyone agrees multiverse theory refutes any fine tuning argument for god. Six arguments that a multiverse is more probable than a god. Evidence of a beginning of the universe from the law of entropy. The argument does not rely on any religious beliefs, but is rather based entirely on modern science and rational philosophy. The multiverse idea is not provable either by observation, or as an implication of well established physics. This collection of universes is often referred to as the string landscape. Sherlock holmes and dr watson went on a camping trip. The multiverse is the conceptualization of multiple dimensions for which our four dimensional universe of spacetime exists within. Sep 07, 2016 the god of this age has blinded the minds of unbelievers, so that they cannot see the light of the gospel of the glory of christ, who is the image of god. May 11, 2018 just a few days before he died, stephen hawking submitted one last research paper using string theory math to talk about the multiverse.
Is it the case that the apparent finetuning of constants and forces to. The extreme case is multiverse proposals, where no direct observational tests of the hypothesis are possible, as the supposed other universes cannot be seen by. Therefore, the belief that god created the multiverse gains credibility, the best hope for the multiverse hypothesis is theism. If the multiverse is all of the possible universes, then god is as allencompassing as anything could be, is the greatest possible being that is necessary, selfexistent, transcending any particular cosmos, and exhibiting all possible moral virtue. According to the multiverse hypothesis, the universe we live in is just one of. The multiverse principle is an attempt to evade evidence for the apparent finetuning of cosmic laws, values and constants such that the universe. Humanitys expanding view of the cosmos stenger, victor j. God could have created a world ensemble brimming with deliberately finely tuned worldsin conclusion the multiverse hypothesis does nothing to eliminate the need for a creator and designer of the universe. The concept of the multiverse is mentioned many times in hindu puranic literature, such as in the bhagavata purana. God and the multiverse are not like harry and lord voldemort. The multiverse, ultimate causation and god the faraday institute. God is not a creative agent, but is the cause or grounding explanation for any particular cosmos. Recent developments in quantum physics postulate the existence of some form of multiverse.
From a physical point of view, the noboundary hartlehawking model put forward in 1983 was an attempt to demonstrate that the incorporation of quantum effects into the general theory of relativity would solve the problem of singularities. Oct 01, 2016 everyone agrees multiverse theory refutes any fine tuning argument for god. The concept of multiverse in hinduism hindu cosmology. The structure of gods multiverse traversing the frequencies history of god workshops and traversing the frequencies are a beyond the source production.
To be clear, some physicists draw a marked distinction between string theory and the multiverse, arguing that string theory is testable in principle and thus perfectly scientific, because the strings are potentially detectable. Having read at least a dozen books on cosmology over the last 8 years or so, i believe victor stengers book, god and the multiverse, is the best because he does such an excellent job of explaining difficult scientific concepts in ways that are understandable as he traces the historical development of cosmology from ancient times until the present. However, he still admitted what is now known as the god of the gaps argument. If an infinite number of universes, did god create all of them. Just a few days before he died, stephen hawking submitted one last research paper using string theory math to talk about the multiverse. How would god, if there is a god, relate to a multiverse. Oct 14, 2019 some theist idealistsscotus erigena is an examplehold that there is no absolute distinction between the physical and the nonphysical. The multiverse theory is increasingly popular, but it doesnt so much explain the laws of physics as dodge the whole issue. Evidence of a beginning of the universe or any multiverse in which it might be situated from the vantage point of spacetime geometry. There could however be scientific evidence in favour of the existence of a multiverse.
Were erigena to support a theist multiverse, he would probably hold that all the universes are constituted by divine ideas. Recent developments in quantum physics postulate the existence of some form of multiverse, often considered inimical to theism. Pdf this work explores the nature of god in the multiverse according to paul c. God, stephen hawking and the multiverse by hutchings, david. The god of this age has blinded the minds of unbelievers, so that they cannot see the light of the gospel of the glory of christ, who is the image of god. No matter how improbable an individual universe is, the probability that it exists if a multiverse. Feb 14, 2015 john lennox, william lane craig, jp moreland. The chapter begins by summarizing how the structure of an argument from the finetuning of a single universe to the existence of god can be expressed in terms of bayes theorem. Such is the advice from bernard carr in grappling with the fascinating discovery that the physics of the universe had to be finetuned if it were to support life. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
1520 1174 694 1185 10 1565 929 312 1237 1258 820 1352 1114 914 988 746 214 1119 1098 427 395 1568 1353 346 1201 992 808 1038 568